I went to email customer service at Wantable to get a return started on the broken eyeshadow quad and she emailed me back asking if I would like a replacement item. I figured it couldn't hurt so I went with it. Well, I got the box and here's what's inside!
Well, Mirabella doesn't carry this eyeshadow trio anymore so I can't verify the price, but the eyeshadow quads are going for $49.00. The shadows are not the most pigmented with a dry brush, but I like the neutral colors (surprise surprise). Overall, fairly happy with it. And bonus, this is the first Makeup Wantable box I've kept all the items in! Yay!